Rt. Rev. Francis J. Desmond, 1952 - 1961

Rev. Francis J. McDonough, 1961 - 1967

Rev. Henry L. Whalen, 1967 - 1969

Rev. John Kavanaugh, 1969 - 1971

Rt. Rev. John J. McGee, 1971 - 1974

Rev. Francis P. Cornely, 1974 - 1975

Rev. Joseph Woods, OSFS (temporary), 1975 - 1976

Rev. Bruce Byrolly, 1976 - 1988

Rev. Philip P. Sheekey, 1988 - 2000

Rev. Raymond L. Forester, 2000 - 2013

Rev. Joseph J. Piekarski, 2013 - 2015

Rev. William T. Cocco, 2015 -